What would you do if you stumbled upon a baby abandoned on church steps? For Benny and Timothy Finnegan, two young brothers in 1940s New Jersey, the answer was clear: bring her home, save her, and let compassion lead the way. Carolyn Summer Quinn’s The Mystery from Way Back When takes this singular act of humanity and unspools it into a blend of stories that connect generations, neighborhoods, and entire communities. It’s a reminder that no story exists in isolation and that each choice we make has the power to echo far beyond our own lives.
A World in a Neighborhood
Keighry Head, Elizabeth, New Jersey, serves as both a microcosm of mid-20th-century America and a vibrant stage for this unforgettable tale. In Quinn’s hands, the streets of this close-knit yet turbulent community come alive with cultural nuance. The Irish Finnegans, the German-American Adlers, and the Italian Donatellas are not just neighbors but players in a larger story of resilience, migration, and hope. Through Benny and Timothy’s small act of heroism, Quinn highlights the way communities can serve as bridges between cultures and generations, showcasing humanity’s interconnectedness.
The Central Mystery: Who Was She?
The abandoned baby, found on the steps of Sacred Heart Church, becomes the heart of the novel’s central mystery: who was her mother, and why was she left behind? But the story doesn’t rest solely on solving this question. Instead, it explores the ripples created by the boys’ discovery. As we follow the baby’s journey from anonymity to belonging, we are reminded that the most profound mysteries are not always solved but lived, woven into the fabric of those they touch.
Why Stories Matter
Quinn masterfully uses this tale to explore a larger question: why do stories matter? Benny’s memories of his father, stationed overseas during World War II, reveal the resilience of a generation raised amid uncertainty. The anecdotes about neighborhood figures—like the tough yet kind Father Paul, or the Adler family, who endure suspicion due to their German roots—bring historical events into deeply personal focus. These stories remind us that history isn’t just a series of dates; it’s the accumulation of countless lives, choices, and connections. How often do we stop to listen to the stories that shape the world around us?
Hope in Every Detail
Quinn’s attention to historical detail is remarkable, not for its dry precision but for its emotional resonance. For instance, Benny’s mother’s pride in their “blue star family” status (signifying a loved one in active military service) adds depth to their struggles, while also illuminating a broader cultural moment. Did you know there were over 350,000 blue star families in the United States during WWII? Details like this enrich the narrative, grounding the Finnegans’ story in a larger historical context while maintaining its emotional core.
A Universal Message Across Borders
Though set in New Jersey, The Mystery from Way Back When speaks to universal truths about family, community, and the enduring power of kindness. The themes of abandonment, resilience, and belonging transcend cultural boundaries, making the story relatable to readers from all walks of life. What does it mean to take responsibility for a stranger? How does one act of love change the world? Quinn’s novel invites readers to grapple with these questions, offering no easy answers but plenty of wisdom.
Conclusion: A Story Worth Crossing Waters For
This isn’t just a book about a mystery; it’s a story about connection—across time, space, and generations. Carolyn Summer Quinn has crafted a tale that will resonate with anyone who values the power of stories to bring us closer, to inspire compassion, and to remind us of our shared humanity. In The Mystery from Way Back When, you’ll find a piece of yourself, no matter where you call home.
Content Warning: The book includes themes of abandonment and explores prejudices of the WWII era, but these are handled with sensitivity, ensuring that the story’s ultimate message of hope remains front and center.
Words Across the Waters Book Award
The book is a Words Across the Waters Book Award winner, celebrated as one of the books that go beyond the surface and offer readers deep cultural insights and transformative experiences. Whether a work of fiction, memoir, or poetry collection, we seek stories that are not only well-crafted but also offer windows into the lives, traditions, and histories that shape our world. Our award-winning books challenge us to see through the eyes of others, face unfamiliar experiences, and reflect on the universal themes that bind us together.
We’d love to hear from you!
What are your thoughts on this piece? Share your insights in the comments below!
- What stood out to you most about this post?
- Have you read a book recently that relates to the themes discussed here?
- What’s your favorite takeaway or reflection from this write-up?
Let’s keep the conversation going—your thoughts make this space richer!
Disclaimer: The content on this site is provided for informational and inspirational purposes only. While we strive for accuracy, the views expressed in reviews, articles, and recommendations are subjective and may not reflect the opinions of all readers.
We receive complimentary copies of all books we review. However, this practice does not compromise the integrity or honesty of our reviews. Every write-up reflects the contributor’s genuine impressions and critical analysis, ensuring transparency and trust with our readers.
For a complete understanding of our practices, please refer to our full Disclaimer, Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service. These documents outline how we manage your information, ensure transparency, and uphold your rights as a user.
To request for a review, to nominate your favorite book for an award, or for more details about our awards, click here.
Other Stories
Grieving Ic by Edward Michael Supranowicz
What does a feeling look like when it turns symmetrical? Spend time with Edward Michael Supranowicz’s artwork, let its forms speak, and discover meaning by lingering with the image quietly.
Book Review: The Stress Book by Dr. D. Terrence Foster
If an octopus could text, juggle, cook, plan a future, soothe trauma, and still feel behind—would it read The Stress Book? You’ll find out why that’s relevant as you read on.
Once A King, Now A Prince by Ira Blacker
What happens when imagination becomes a survival skill instead of a pastime? Once A King, Now A Prince by Ira Blacker reveals the answer—if you’re willing to follow the journey.
OneTribune 
